When the Donut Man suggests that the theme of the Christmas play could be the gifts that we all can bring Jesus, little Katie is embarrassed as she compares her home,made gift with the more expensive, store,bought gifts. But in the end, she is reassured that in the same way that Jesus gave her the best present of all, His love, she has returned that gift with the best present she could give to God, the gift of herself. Songs include: "O Come All Ye Faithful", "Joy to the World", "Gentle Mary, Humble Mary", "What Can I Give?", "You Are the Lamb of God", "The Best Present of All", and "Happy Birthday, Jesus".